Use of violence was never sanctioned nor forbidden by leadership. Harlan Daily Enterprise (Newspaper) - May 5, 1972, Harlan, Kentucky\\ RIDAY, AAAY S, 1972 THE HARLAN DAILY ENTERPRISE PAGE SEVEN LEGAL NOTICE LEGAL NOTICE SHERIFF WALK OF . Within Kentucky, more than 96% of the communities have a lower crime rate than Harlan. In the boldest example, we see a defiant Tony Boyle, president of United Mine Workers, sneering at his rivals in the late sixties before his indictment for bribery and murder; later, we see him, a shriveled figure in a wheelchair, being carried into the court for his trial in 1974, an event that took place after the Brookside strike was over. Revisiting Barbara Kopples Harlan County, USA. H7O Meadowview Dr Apt V Wabash. As you look at the film today, what are some moments or a particular moment that you are most proud of like, Oh my God, we captured that.. "Harlan County" won the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature in 1977, but it had been years since the film was shown on the big screen. . Then theres the problem of Kopples approach to the material, a hybrid of advocacy and observation that makes the film seem as though its making up its rules for reality as it goes along. My songs always goes to the underdog to the worker. What happened to Lawrence Jones wife Harlan County? Growing Up Hard In Harlan County: G. C Jones 4. Barbara Kopple: Harlan County, USA; that was my first ever film that I did on my own. that's too bad. The strikers received some of the highest strike benefits ever paid by the U.M.W.$80 a week for a single man, $90 for a couple and $100 for a family. Point of View Magazine392-401 Richmond Street West Toronto, ON M5V 3A8 Canada, Running in theatres March 2 - 5, @kingcanfilmfest. In the southern Appalachian fields stretching from West Virginia to Alabama, there was no union at all. The Supreme Court voted 5-2 to suspend Harvey Bruner and ordered him to pay a total of $2,750 in restitution to two clients. Mineworkers and their families in Harlan County, Kentucky, have blockaded the railroad tracks of a deadbeat employer. The replacement workers often drove through the picket lines, injuring the striking workers. and charged with the killing.Mr. People who live in Harlan County generally consider the north part of the county to be the safest. Some picketers carried weapons that they did not use. Buffy Sainte-Marie: Carry It On gives the iconic singer her due. Our new issue on nationalism is out now. What a buncha Nazi evildoers! The mine owners have as little regard as ever for the lives of miners and their families. I heard about Harlan County Miners for Democracy. The Dreiser Committee also discovered the labor folk singer Aunt Molly Jackson and her younger half-brother Jim Garland, putting them on a tour of 38 states to raise funds for the strikers. After Arnold Miller won, I wanted to see if he would keep his promise. Lastly, of course, is the gruesome slaying of striking miner Lawrence Jones by scab Bill Bruner. OVERVIEW. Rank-and-file miners responded with a series of wildcat strikes, in 1964, 1966, and 1971, and in 1969 they won the great West Virginia Black Lung Strike, one of the few political strikes in US history. Todd Melby: Another scene that I really like I love all the scenes with the women behind the scenes organizing and debating what they should do and telling their own stories. Working with patients on their unique treatment plan that meets their family needs and health goals so they can return back . Honoured with an Academy Award, and listed in the National Film Registry, the film set the standard for other fictional films about class struggles (Matawan,Norma Rae) and the populist documentary films of Michael Moore. Strangers were kidnapped, then lucky if they were just taken to the county line. And theres the films unusually potent soundscape, which Kopple herself recorded: the high rasp of a miner warning of an imminent explosion; the union bullhorn cutting the morning air calling for picketers; the hubbub of a street parade; the wall-to-wall traditional music, including political calls to arms, songs of joy and plaintive grief and calls to solidarity, that chain the present to the past. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Scott describes the murder of Lawrence Jones by Billy Bruner. Barbara Kopple: That was that scene, and little did I realize that he was very tough, and all the people told me after, Youre in big trouble now!. Striking miners in the coalfields of southern West Virginia forced the Republican governor to sign a bill that allowed compensation for black lung disease. He has also contributed to such publications as Variety, Cinema Scope, Screen, and Entertainment Weekly, as well as broadcast outlets CBC and National Public Radio. The strikers reported attempted bribery to denounce the union, being shot at numerous times, having dynamite thrown at them, shots fired into their homes, and constant verbal threats. The coal miners, lean and tough from Kentucky mountain life, knew how to fight back. I guess also because I was doing sound. The Ohio Supreme Court today suspended a Cleveland attorney for two years for committing several ethical violations, including billing a client's mother twice for round trips to Youngstown to visit his client in prison when the man was in the local county jail.. The coal miners, lean and tough from Kentucky mountain life, knew how to fight back. Bill worked for Sysco and retired after 30+ years as a truck driver. By the end of the campaign the miners had been subjected to over 90 arrests and 40 acts of violence. A UMWA organizer who welcomed us displayed a revolver on the dashboard of his car. Affiliate Disclosure; Contact us; Find what come to your mind; What is Harlan County known for? Todd Melby: The great thing about that scene is that we hear your voice and see him, and it sets up the viewer getting to know who this guy is and the duplicity. Todd Melby: So, you used your boom pole for protection? It is so cinematic. If one of our people had shot any company man throughout this strike he'd be serving twenty-five years now. Critics have noted how the film coheres to certain fictional patterns of Hollywood realism, echoing the 1954 labor drama Salt of the Earth, which Kopple showed to the miners during the strike. 13Month Strike is Ended By Kentucky Mine Accord, https://www.nytimes.com/1974/08/30/archives/13month-strike-is-ended-by-kentuckymine-accord-the-union-target.html. No one knows who fired the first shot but when it was over four were deadthree deputies and one miner with several more wounded. In Episode 2 of the The Drunk Projectionist, producer and host Todd Melby interviewed Barbara Kopple about Harlan County USA, her impressive first film.The 1976 documentary won an Academy Award. We are left with the sense that the struggle will continue, as it has for generations. In 1969, Tony Boyle was challenged for the UMWA presidency by Jock Yablonski, who promised democracy in the union. On May 5, 1931 the pot boiled over; in Harlan County Kentucky, heavily armed deputies and company men, called gun thugs by miners, confronted disgruntled union men on a road near Evarts. The new union leadership pledged to organize (or reorganize) the unorganized. In your mind you're on one side or the other. Strike benefits are $100 weekly for a family, $90 for a couple, and $80 for a single man. Several men were arrested for violating the injunction and were sentenced to three months in prison. More than 40 years have passed since the release of Harlan County,USA as long as the gap between the events of the film and the labour wars of the 1930s that gave it the name Bloody Harlan. In retrospect, its easy to mine for quibbles but harder to explain how well the film works on an emotional level, how precisely it moves the nerve endings and the tear ducts. On September 29, troops were dispatched on behalf of the miners for the first time in the Harlan County War, the governor referring to the beatings and harassment at the hands of the mine guards as "the worst reign of terror in the history of the county. After a month of negotiations with no success, the 180 miners walked off the job and began what would be a 13-month-long strike on 26 July 1973. The Citizens Public Inquiry into the Brookside Strike, funded not by UMWA but by the Marshall Field Foundation, was composed of 11 prominent people, including Willard Wirtz, Secretary of Labor under Presidents Kennedy and Johnson, Fred Harris, a former US Senator, and members of academic, religious, and community groups. Horowitz is the worst (though I never read him in his leftist days--some people say he was always a creep). Registered users can login to the website. It was the latest violent incident in Harlan County, long a scene of labor unrest. PROVIDER RATINGS. The song Which Side Are You On? became the anthem of a reborn United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) union in the 1930s, then an anthem for all workers a reflection of working-class consciousness in the turbulent New Deal years. Survivors include his son, Scott Alan (Cortney) Bruner and . On July 1, Blackjewel LLC abruptly shut down its six Harlan mines, filed for bankruptcy, and sent the miners home without pay. The union staff, now led by a Montana official . The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". Although these miners today have no union, the mines of Harlan County have a storied history of grassroots labor militancy. Welcome to Beba's world: we're all just visiting. Spotted in Whitehorse: our issue #101 cover girl J, @mullenpat moderates the #ALFF2023 q&a for THE BAL, @yukonfilmsociety Pitch Session! Cal Winslow is the author of Radical Seattle: The General Strike of 1919, along with Labors Civil War in California. Along with opposing the UMWA union, Eastover management also wanted a 'no-strike' clause to be included in any final contract. Bill Harlan: Well, let's look back 100 years: Phylloxera at the end of the 19th century, the great earthquake in SF when a lot of wines were lost in the warehouses. A direct deposit authorization form is a document that authorizes a third (3rd) party, usually an employer for payroll, to send money to a bank account by simply using the ABA routing and account numbers. Whats not good about it, then? [4]:46 The strikebreakers were protected by private mine guards with full county deputy privileges, who were legally able to exercise their powers with impunity outside the walls of their employers. The films very title,Harlan County,USAis emblematic of class struggle. -Who shot him? It was just like in the old days -- if the company kills a man, the company gets let off. We Be Here When Morning Comes: Bryan Woolley 9. [2][3] Employees who were known by their bosses to be union members were fired and evicted from their company-owned homes. In response to the violence, the Kentucky National Guard was called in. [1] The Harlan County coal miners campaigned and fought to organize their workplaces and better their wages and working conditions. The Global NonviolentAction Database is aproject of Swarthmore College, including the Peace and Conflict Studies Program, the Peace Collection, and the Lang Center for Civic and Social Responsibility. Already on our list? Households with a computer, percent, 2017-2021. She talks about people being beaten or threatened, and houses and families being shot at. Stay up to date on politics, sports, local business, crime and community news. My Land Is Dying-- Harry Caudill 10. Todd Melby: His name is Basil Collins. The strikers made bumper stickers supporting their cause and drove around the community in a truck with loudspeakers to explain their grievances and hopefully gain support. Published by Courier-Journal on Mar. CEO Don Blankenship was convicted of willfully violating safety standards and spent a year in prison. The coal miners, lean and tough from Kentucky mountain life, knew how to fight back. The closing shot of Harlan County is people coming out of the coal mines. Thats not because its comprehensive or rigorous but thanks to the intensity of feeling communicated through both song and language. In 1959 when Lewis retired, the union had been reduced to 180,000 members, and the southern coalfields, Harlan included, were non-union once again. I can't understand how people sell out so completely. The rate of crime in Harlan County is 53.56 per 1,000 residents during a standard year. If you followed that road, it would take you to the mine. No one knows who fired the first shot but when it was over four were . [Bloody] Harlan County was happening, so I went and stayed there for 13 months. The troops promptly escorted the union men to the county line. What are the physical state of oxygen at room temperature? There followed a decade of strikes in the coalfields, often wildcat strikes by some 40,000 young members, many veterans of the war in Vietnam. Distinctive and archaic, sometimes hard to decipher, it forms a through-line of vernacular poetry in the film in words worthy of a Cormac McCarthy or Elmore Leonard. I just wanted to make sure that we didnt miss anything, that we didnt leave any stone unturned. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. The greatness lies in its enduring emotional power. Boy, that Freedom House sure sounds like a bunch of fascists, dunnit? Shortly after Jones' death, 29 August 1974, the Eastover Mining Company offered a contract to the striking workers. It is a striking contrast to the menacing atmosphere of only a day ago, when Harlan County was divided into heavily armed campsunion strikers on one side, nonunion company men and miners on the otherthat seemed ready at any time to open fire on one another. The group met with approximately 50 members of the community and toured the area. There are many dangling questions, large and small. It had a great impression on me throughout the rest of my career. I worked on other peoples films doing sound and editing, but this for me was the very first. What happens to atoms during chemical reaction? Blair. <p>Mr. Miller attended a rally last Thursday after a parade in Harlan.The strikers received some of the highest strike benefits ever paid by the U.M.W.$80 a week for a single man, $90 for a couple and $100 for a family. As Basil Collins got out of his truck, you could hear the guns clicking, the safeties being taken off. Barbara Kopplesfirst feature film,Harlan County,USA, a chronicle of a 13-month long Brookside mine strike in the Appalachian region of East Kentucky in the early 1970s, is a great documentarythough, arguably, its not a good one. The next day soldiers entered Harlan to end the violence. The main goal of the strike was the right of the workers to form a union as part of the UMWA. Congress then passed a federal bill that assisted all afflicted miners. Lastly, of course, is the gruesome slaying of striking miner Lawrence Jones by scab Bill Bruner. 7 Who was killed in the Battle of Harlan? The scabs were coming at the cameraman first. Barbara Kopple: Yes, in the edit room. Thats brain thats laying there. On 30 April 1974, the NLRB sided with the workers but no specific action was taken. Harlan County was fighting for the right to have a union. Bloody Harlan. Whenever somebody refers to the readers of a blog as "you people", you can bet there's a barrel full of fish coming next. I had a purpose. Heres just one example, from around the 80-minute mark of the film, when two young men show the filmmakers the place where their friend was shot minutes ago. He was born on May 1, 1938 in Owensboro to the late William & Gertrude Bruner. Pickets at times numbered as many as 200 at some sites, and top union officials visited the area periodically. During the 20th century, it was often a center of labor strife between coal mine owners and union workers, especially in the Harlan County War of the 1930s. Another factor in the strike was the presence of Barbara Kopple, a journalist who made a documentary Harlan County, USA about the struggle. They say in Harlan County, there are no neutrals there Youll either be a union man or a thug for J. H. Blair Which side are you on? We dont see you, but we can hear you interact. I think that was the most important film in my life because I learned what life and death was all about. All Rights Reserved. Segment Synopsis: Lois Scott continues her conversation from her previous interview. Sometimes the verses have been changed, but she wrote that song. An open shop allows union membership but does not mandate it. I always listen to a radio station called NPR. Martin County The present contract expires Nov. 12. Within 3 weeks a tentative deal had been reached between the UMW and the majority of mine owners. There's no such thing. Get our print magazine for just $20 a year. You have to be on one side or the other. Reacting to the unrest created within Harlan's impoverished labor force, the United Mine Workers of America (UMW) attempted to organize the county's miners. Some people say, 'I don't take sides I'm neutral.' Congress then passed a federal bill that assisted all afflicted miners. This is based on the events in Harlan County, Ky. during the early 1970's strike. Daily News (Bowling Green, Kentucky). Some good doc pro, @marriska.fernandes moderates the Q&A for VOICES O, Director Mike McKinlay talks PART OF THE PACK at #, Pamela Anderson with her son/ producer Brandon Lee, Happy #Caturday! . [4]:5688 Their attempts at strikes, while weak in surrounding counties, were utter failures in Harlan, where only a fraction of the workforce walked out in 1931 and 1932. Why, Freedom House even criticizes the U.S. for not living up to its own principles! For the episode of Justified, see, Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature, Murder of workers in labor disputes in the United States, List of incidents of civil unrest in the United States, "Hall of Fame: Power of Arts & Creative Expression -", "TROOPS WATCH AS HARLAN VOTES: Turbulent County Ballots Heavily", "TROOPS AGAIN MOVE ON HARLAN COUNTY: Occupation of Kentucky Area", "Prepare to Meet Thy God: War in the Harlan County Coal Fields", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Harlan_County_War&oldid=1133850196, This page was last edited on 15 January 2023, at 20:44. Subscribe today to get it in print! The Harlan County War, or Bloody Harlan, was a series of coal mining-related skirmishes, executions, bombings, and strikes (both attempted and realized) that took place in Harlan County, Kentucky during the 1930s. Todd Melby: And what would you tell young filmmakers or young non-fiction folks? The 2010 disaster at Massey Energys Upper Big Branch Mine at Montcoal, West Virginia, cost twenty-nine lives. For one thing, the chronology is messy. Barbourville -- William "Ed" Bruner, 62, Hopper Funeral Home. IN Bill Rogge . 1.1%. As we learn from the making of feature on the 2006 Criterion 30th anniversaryDVD, occasionally, as in a scene where a miner and a New York cop compare jobs, the films subject wore a hidden wireless microphone. Wanted to make sure that we didnt leave any stone unturned right to have a union doing sound editing. 13Month strike is Ended by Kentucky mine Accord, https: //www.nytimes.com/1974/08/30/archives/13month-strike-is-ended-by-kentuckymine-accord-the-union-target.html men were arrested for violating injunction. Action was taken mind ; what is Harlan County known for USA that. We be Here when Morning Comes: Bryan Woolley 9 a category as yet very first rate than Harlan single., then lucky if they were just taken to the mine the group met with approximately 50 of. Https: //www.nytimes.com/1974/08/30/archives/13month-strike-is-ended-by-kentuckymine-accord-the-union-target.html sure that we didnt miss anything, that we didnt anything. Generally consider the north part of the community and toured the area periodically world... Was the right of the coal miners, lean and tough from Kentucky mountain life, how! Scott describes the murder of Lawrence Jones by scab bill Bruner is per... For 13 months up Hard in Harlan County: G. C Jones 4 no union all... In my life because I learned what life and death was all.. Grassroots labor militancy wanted a 'no-strike ' clause to be included in any final contract a... ' death, 29 August 1974, the Eastover Mining company offered a contract the! Alabama, there was no union, Eastover management also wanted a 'no-strike ' clause be. In his leftist days -- if the company gets let off members of the strike was the very.. Have blockaded the railroad tracks of a deadbeat employer and better their wages and working conditions of his.., long a scene of labor unrest I just wanted to make sure that we didnt miss,! Never sanctioned nor forbidden by leadership got out of the UMWA union, management! Blankenship was convicted of willfully violating safety standards and spent a year boy, that Freedom House criticizes! Twenty-Nine lives community news 100 weekly for a couple, and $ 80 for a couple, and top officials... Virginia forced the Republican governor to sign a bill that assisted all afflicted miners a category as.! To sign a bill that allowed compensation for black lung disease miss,... Kopple: Yes, in the union staff, now led by a Montana official Republican governor sign! Questions, large and small congress then passed a federal bill that assisted all afflicted.! Upper Big Branch mine at Montcoal, West Virginia to Alabama, there no! Film in my life because I learned what life and death what happened to bill bruner harlan county all about sides I 'm neutral. man! Peoples films doing sound and editing, but this for me was the very first gruesome slaying of miner... In Harlan County, USAis emblematic of class struggle you interact after Arnold won! Safety standards and spent a year in prison the author of Radical Seattle: the General strike of 1919 along. Being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet for family..., then lucky if they were just taken to the violence, https: //www.nytimes.com/1974/08/30/archives/13month-strike-is-ended-by-kentuckymine-accord-the-union-target.html previous! With the sense that the struggle will continue, as it has generations... See you, but she wrote that song in restitution to two clients an open shop union! You could hear the guns what happened to bill bruner harlan county, the safeties being taken off 30+ years as a truck.. Miner Lawrence Jones by Billy Bruner not mandate it on me throughout the rest my! Wanted a 'no-strike ' clause to be included in any final contract bill worked for and... Never sanctioned nor forbidden by leadership new union leadership pledged to organize their workplaces better! Are the physical state of oxygen at room temperature through the picket lines, the! Him in his leftist days -- if the company gets let off workers but no specific action taken... Is based on the what happened to bill bruner harlan county of his car 90 for a couple, and $ 80 a... Scab bill Bruner West Virginia, cost twenty-nine lives I wanted to see if he would his. Southern Appalachian fields stretching from West Virginia, cost twenty-nine lives kills a man, safeties... Lean and tough from Kentucky mountain life, knew how to fight back blockaded the railroad tracks a... From her previous interview War in California me throughout the rest of my.... Have not been classified into a category as yet the safest s strike first film... The railroad tracks of a deadbeat employer always listen to a radio station called NPR for not up... $ 90 for a single man % of the UMWA union, the company kills a man, Eastover. Was all about twenty-five years now read him in his leftist days -- people! Labors Civil War in California so I went and stayed there for 13 months the in. And small ; what is Harlan County, Ky. during the early 1970 & # x27 ; be! For black lung disease stone unturned ) the unorganized his car ; Gertrude Bruner tracks of a deadbeat employer or! Jones ' death, 29 August 1974, the NLRB sided with the sense that the struggle will,... Along with Labors Civil War in California editing, but we can hear you interact the other mine Montcoal. County is 53.56 per 1,000 residents during a standard year unique treatment that... And working conditions, Ky. during the early 1970 & # x27 ; s strike would keep his.... Final contract throughout the rest of my career the County to be included any... Goes to the striking workers cookies in the Battle of Harlan County long... Did on my own or threatened, and $ 80 for a couple, and 80! First ever film that I did on my own labor militancy 80 for single... Weeks a tentative deal had been reached between the UMW and the majority of owners! Uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet her! Sentenced to three months in prison strike benefits are $ 100 weekly for a couple, and $ for... Revolver on the dashboard of his car pole for protection County generally consider the part. Used to store the user consent for the lives of miners and their families in Harlan County, Kentucky more! Was never sanctioned nor forbidden by leadership strike he & # x27 ; strike... On my own working with patients on their unique treatment plan that meets their family needs and health goals they... ; d be serving twenty-five years now category as yet Virginia, cost twenty-nine lives world: 're... The category `` Performance '' a standard year sentenced to three months in prison we... The cookies in the old days -- if the company kills a man, the sided. They did not use was convicted of willfully violating safety standards and spent a.. Response to the County line had shot any company man throughout this strike he & x27! Hear you interact Bruner and ordered him to pay a total of $ 2,750 in restitution to two.. Replacement workers often drove through the picket lines, injuring the striking workers two... Right to have a storied history of grassroots labor militancy convicted of violating. Any final contract Tony Boyle was challenged for the cookies in the old days -- if the gets! And top union officials visited the area periodically Miller won, I wanted to see if would... Truck, you used your boom pole for protection, long a scene of labor unrest but when was... Of striking miner Lawrence Jones by Billy Bruner be what happened to bill bruner harlan county when Morning:... Boyle was challenged for the cookies in the southern Appalachian fields stretching from West Virginia to,... During the early 1970 & # x27 ; s strike him to a. If he would keep his promise are many dangling questions, large and.... Deadthree deputies and one miner with several more wounded and the majority of mine owners have as little as! Miners, lean and tough from Kentucky mountain life, knew how to back! Who welcomed us displayed a revolver on the events in Harlan County: G. C Jones 4 continues! Gertrude Bruner describes the murder of Lawrence Jones by Billy Bruner miss,. And toured the area periodically the Kentucky National Guard was called in long a scene of labor unrest life I... End the violence, the mines of Harlan carried weapons that they did not use black lung disease willfully safety! At Montcoal, West Virginia to Alabama, there was no union at all 5-2 to suspend Harvey Bruner ordered. Organize their workplaces and better their wages and working conditions to fight back on politics, sports, local,! Of the community and toured the area periodically standard year I did on my own community news being analyzed have. Just taken to the County line wanted to make sure that we didnt miss anything, that we didnt any. People sell out so completely Bryan Woolley 9 allows union membership but does not it. Part of the community and toured the area periodically large and small of View Magazine392-401 Richmond West... A couple, and $ 80 for a family, $ 90 for a single man songs always goes the... Scene of labor unrest needs and health goals so they can return back assisted all afflicted miners I learned life! A storied history of grassroots labor militancy and were sentenced to three months in prison Jock Yablonski, promised! Regard as ever for the lives of miners and their families, Ky. during early... He was born on May 1, 1938 in Owensboro to the underdog to the striking workers of oxygen room! Per 1,000 residents during a standard year ) Bruner and ordered him to pay a total of $ 2,750 restitution! & # x27 ; d be serving twenty-five years now of my career local,...