Tebovle Phone number. In 1846 he brought his new wife, Frances Marie Glidden Howe, to Lima and built a home for them, the Greek revival frame building still standing at the east end of the former campus. [A]ctual fraud may not be based on representations regarding future conduct, or on broken promises, unfulfilled predictions or statements of existing intent which are not executed. Lycan, 904 F.Supp. To the contrary, "summary judgment is proper 'where the plaintiff presents no indication of motive or intent supportive of his position.' Tebovle Postal address. [2] The school opened in the former home of Mr. and Mrs. Howe, built in 1844, with two boys. See id. Amendments to pleadings should be freely given when justice so requires. Jane C.'s motion urged the court to reconsider its grant of summary judgment because she maintained that Merritt and Cowles had not produced all of the evidence she had requested. 3,280 were here. Two questions are relevant to this determination: (a) whether each plaintiff's case retained its separate identity and, if not, (b) whether the district court in fact disposed of all the claims, rendering the case appealable even in the absence of a formal Rule 58 judgment. Jennings Canteen, and Howe Mansion all by Carlson Productions, LLC, Royal Oak, MI. P. 4(a)(4)(A)(iv). and demanding course of study. The Zacher Company, a Fort Wayne real estate firm, placed a description of the 63 . Howe reached its biggest enrollment in history in 1966-67: 458; by 1978-79 that had fallen to 248 and kept falling to less than 100 as the anti-war hostility took its toll on all military prep schools. Specifically, they allege that John R. Giles, a U.S. Army Sergeant who worked as a Military Instructor and Tactical Officer at the school, sexually abused them repeatedly. The School hosted an Army Junior ROTC unit from 1918 until it closed in 2019. In this case, the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying the Does' motions to amend the pleadings. At the time of enrollment, Jane C. was 14 and Jane R. was 15. Second, both Does argue that the district court should have granted them leave to amend their complaints. It takes about $5 million a year to operate HMA. LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT (LD) IS REQUIRED OF ALL CADETS--GRADES 9 THROUGH 12. 3:95-CV-206, and the Scheduling Order entered in 3:95-CV-206 shall govern these five consolidated cases. It began originally as an all boys school, until 1998 when it became a coeducational institution. Second, we find that the district court's orders of June 21, 1999, demonstrate that the court understood that by resolving Jane C.'s fraud claim, it was resolving the last outstanding claim of the consolidated case; the manner in which judgment was entered on this claim demonstrates that the district court meant to terminate the consolidated case as a whole. In support of this allegation, the Yateses contended only that two white students who were identically accused were not expelled. Learn more about FindLaws newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy. In addition to the picturesque Karlov Square with City Hall and the Gothic Church of St. Bartholomew with bell tower, the surviving walls of the Prchovna bastion and several churches are also worth seeing. Three portions of the "Rules and Regulations" are also relevant to this case. Later orders related to these cases were issued under docket number 3:95-CV-206 (which had originally pertained only to Jane R.'s case), often with the notation consolidated somewhere in the caption. The Class of 2019 graduated on June 1, 2019 and was Howe's 135th and. No, we dont want to do that. They also wanted to amend their pleading against defendant Giles in the event the court granted Giles's motion for judgment on the evidence. See Norman v. Turkey Run Community School Corp., 274 Ind. Howe has JROTC with great. See all. As the defendants argued in their summary judgment briefs, the Yateses failed to allege any facts from which such discrimination can be inferred. Jane C. claims that the defendants failed to inform her that the conduct of students and employees could be inappropriate and even dangerous, that the defendants did not provide her with this information out of their desire to induce her to attend the school (as part of a plan to increase female enrollment to bring in more tuition dollars), and that this omission of material fact amounted to constructive fraud. Jones . Dr. McKenzie had previously headed Ohio Military Institute and, for its first year, Culver Military Academy. His two daughters were also important to Howes history: Katharine married Burrett B. Bouton, who was superintendent from 1934 to his passing in 1963. For many years, the Howe house has been the home of the chaplain who serves Howe Military Academy. Therefore, a separate Rule 58 judgment specifically terminating Jane R.'s case was unnecessary, and our jurisdiction over both parties' appeals is secure. In the same order, the court also dismissed the two Title IX claims (Counts I and II) as time-barred. Whether the grant or denial of leave to amend was proper is a question we review for abuse of discretion. The non-moving party cannot rest on the pleadings alone, but must designate specific facts in affidavits, depositions, answers to interrogatories or admissions that establish that there is a genuine triable issue. Each of the plaintiffs is black and is an Illinois domiciliary. If you have a Limited Time Fundraisers for family are ok. 6. As the judge observed, the motions did not state what specifically the Does planned to allege in their amended pleadings. The Does' request to amend consisted of the following: In the alternative, plaintiffs request that they be permitted to amend their complaints to more specifically allege a claim against the individual defendants, Merritt and Cowles, under Title IX, or, in the alternative, to state a claim against the individual defendants, Merritt and Cowles, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. The Honorable Hubert L. Will, Senior District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, is sitting by designation, One of the boys withdrew from the school rather than accept the suspension. At bottom, the Does wanted another shot in the event their claims were dismissed. She said only that she saw Cowles and Merritt from time to time around the school and that her only personal contact with both defendants was when she went to them to appeal some demerits. Jane C. filed a motion to alter or amend the judgment and for relief from judgment under Fed.R.Civ.P. Both women left the home in the late 1960s and did not bring suit until 1990, well into adulthood. R.App. As it turned out, Jane C.'s case was the last of the five cases to be fully resolved. All rights reserved. Furthermore, as Giles points out, it would have been futile to have allowed the Does to amend their complaints to assert a 1983 action, because such an action would also have been time-barred under Indiana's two-year statute of limitations. The school enrolls students in grades 6-12. Howe Military Academy, once hailed as one of the finest military academies in the United States, joined a long list of American military high schools that have closed their doors. See Eckstein, 8 F.3d at 1124-25. Bouton faced two major challenges during his tenure: maintaining enrollment during the Great Depression and Howes great fire when the old academic building burned in 1946. [4], Howe Military did not compete in a conference structure. I also recommend that the parents of these Cadets be notified of this violation. See Glatt v. Chicago Park Dist., 87 F.3d 190, 194 (7th Cir.1996) (holding motion to amend or supplement the complaint, unlike an original complaint, requires more to compel acceptance than the fact that the pleading sought to be added states a claim). Contact info. Years later, Jane R. and Jane C. sued Howe Military School, Giles, Thomas Merritt (Superintendent of Howe), Lawrence E. Cowles (Commandant of Howe), and Timothy L. Cook (Tactical Officer at Howe), the latter three in both their individual and official capacities. After 135 years, Howe Military Academy announced in March, 2019 that it would not be opening for the 2019-2020 school year. L.R.J. character, self-esteem and the determination to succeed throughout their. Philip Morgan, a native of Wales, serving in the Episcopal Church from 1984 was the School Chaplain, and Rector of St. Mark's, Howe from 1986-2000, On March 18, 2019, Howe announced it would be closing its doors due to operational and fiscal challenges. Co., 883 F.2d 1307, 1312 (7th Cir.1989)). Dr. McKenzie was a devout anglo-catholic priest and dynamic leader and fundraiser, whose powerful religious and administrative example was still a campus presence after his passing in 1920, until the end of the 20th century. Wednesday, retired. Article. (The three other plaintiffs whose cases had been consolidated with Jane C.'s and Jane R.'s settled their claims.) Eckstein, 8 F.3d at 1125 (finding district court did not merge consolidated cases where court explicitly stated there was no merger and entered a separate Rule 58 judgment in each individual case). Finally, they contest (fourth) the district court's rulings regarding discovery and (fifth) its denial of Jane C.'s Rule 59(e) motion. The Plaintiffs, Mr. and Mrs. Roy and Lowetta Yates and their son Alexander, instituted this civil rights action against Howe Military School after Alexander was discharged from Howe for an alleged violation of school rules. R. 17 Ex.H. 1983. Because the plaintiffs do not challenge whether it was correct for the district court to borrow the state statute of limitations for the Title IX claims, we do not address whether that ruling was correct. White Hall (Lower School, grades 5-8), the Gymnasium, and the Power Plant were constructed during his tenure. Association of Military Colleges and Schools of the United States, Learn how and when to remove these template messages, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Howe Military Academy closing after 135 years in operation", "Howe Military Academy's closure ends 135 years of classes", "New York religious group pays $3M cash to buy the former Howe Military Academy campus", Virginia Women's Institute for Leadership, Valley Forge Military Academy and College, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Howe_Military_Academy&oldid=1134877972, Military high schools in the United States, Educational institutions established in 1884, Buildings and structures in LaGrange County, Indiana, Short description is different from Wikidata, Wikipedia articles in need of updating from January 2018, All Wikipedia articles in need of updating, Articles needing additional references from January 2017, All articles needing additional references, Articles with multiple maintenance issues, All Wikipedia articles written in American English, Infobox mapframe without OSM relation ID on Wikidata, Articles with unsourced statements from January 2018, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 21 January 2023, at 05:43. But Yates distinguished himself from his two white friends by continuing to deny the allegations in the face of mounting evidence, including confessions by the two white cadets. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. The final publication. Thus, the district court could have granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment on the Yateses' failure to come forth, in response to the defendants' motion for summary judgment, with sufficient factual allegations to create a genuine issue of material fact on the central issue--upon which the Yateses bear the burden of proof--of the defendants' discriminatory motive. Its jewel is the Renaissance synagogue, founded in . Patrick Redmond HOWE The former Howe Military School campus in Howe is about to become busy again. Private schools are not rated. Here, they assert (and we accept for present purposes) that they filed suit within two years of the time when they recognized their injuries. All claims except Jane C.'s fraud claim were dismissed as time barred; discovery could not have changed that fact. PO BOX 240, Howe, IN 46746. In reply, the defendants point out that the two white students confessed to their guilt and asked for special consideration, while Alexander continued to deny his guilt in the face of substantial evidence. 604, 308 N.E.2d 701, 706 (1974). In those circumstances, she may bring the cause of action within two years after the disability is removed. . Wells v. Stone City Bank, 691 N.E.2d 1246, 1250 (Ind.Ct.App.1998). The Indiana Supreme Court came to a different result for each plaintiff. 281 63 Kostelec nad ernmi lesy. All filings in these five consolidated cases shall henceforth be docketed in Cause No. On August 14, 1991, the district court issued a memorandum and order granting the defendants' motion for summary judgment. Choose from thousands of products to decorate, including the newest Howe Military Academy Cadets t-shirts, sweatshirts, hoodies, jerseys, hats, long sleeve shirts, face masks, polos, shorts, sweatpants, and more. The Board examined several witnesses, apparently including Koby and Barton, and concluded that Alexander Yates was guilty as charged. Jestab Lhota Fax number. At the time of enrollment, Jane C. was 14 and Jane R. was 15. I recommend that Cadets Shane Barton, Alexander Yates, and David Koby appear before a General Board to determine their guilt or innocence of the charge: possession and use of an alcoholic beverage. District courts do not have to engage in guessing games about proposed amendments, and the judge here was well within his discretion to deny this motion. a. The Rev. But the full picture includes the undisputed facts that Alexander Yates consistently denied the charge while his cohorts confessed, the General Disciplinary Board found him guilty of the charge after full hearing, and such conduct is considered violative of the Howe Honor Code. of State Revenue, 170 Ind.App. Gutierrez v. Peters, 111 F.3d 1364, 1368 (7th Cir.1997). We have digitized many Tatler yearbooks which can be viewed online. In response, the defendants contest the proposed nexus and suggest that the Yateses waived their Civil Rights Restoration Act argument by failing to raise it before the district court. The court had all of the evidence before it and was intimately familiar with the defendants' conduct during discovery. 321 783 489. International: +420 321 783 489. 50 and 54(b) to enter a final judgment in her case. Following Turkey Run, we believe that Indiana would not require a school to outline the worst case scenario that a potential or actual student could confront, since its duty is only to exercise reasonable care. In the 1919 catalog, parents are told that Payments should be made by draft on New York or Chicago, payable to J. H. McKenzie, Rector, not to Howe School. Their oldest son, Larry, was a Trustee for many years. Eric Holcomb's eyes looked like they might pop out of his head Friday afternoon as two Howe Military School cadets presented . Estates of Kalwitz v. Kalwitz, 717 N.E.2d 904, 913 (Ind.Ct.App.1999). Her discussion of the missing evidence did not convince the court that the grant of summary judgment was improper. The former Lower School building was remodeled into the Administration Building. At the end of the 20182019 school year, the school was closed and put on the market. Replacement of the Academic Building was difficult; the new building was not dedicated until 1950. If you wish to pay by check, please mail to the above South Bend address. of the cottages at the S.C. Governor's School for Agriculture at John de la Howe while giving a tour of the . The first count alleged that the discrimination constituted a breach of the Student Enrollment Contract, specifically its statement that "[t]he philosophy and objectives of Howe Military School conform to the basic principles of American Democracy", in violation of Indiana law. As for the historic campus itself, Howes board has not discussed any plans of what theyll do with it. [A] cause of action for a tort claim accrues and the statute of limitations begins to run when the plaintiff knew, or in the exercise of ordinary diligence, could have discovered that an injury had been sustained as a result of the tortious act of another. Wehling v. Citizens Nat'l Bank, 586 N.E.2d 840, 843 (Ind.1992); see also, Burks v. Rushmore, 534 N.E.2d 1101, 1103-04 (Ind.1989). See Fed. 's claims were not time-barred because she had no memory of the events and had presented sufficient facts to invoke the equitable doctrine of fraudulent concealment, which tolled the statute of limitations. With respect to Title VI, the Yateses argue that the district court erred in two respects in concluding that Grove City College barred their claim. There are several problems with Jane C.'s allegations of actual fraud. A devout anglo-catholic Episcopalian, John Howes will left three $10,000 bequests to the Church: one to establish a grammar school for boys at Lima, another to Nashotah House, then as now the foremost anglo-catholic seminary in the U.S., and a third bequest to St. Marks Parish, Lima (now Howe) for a new church. The court found the section 1981 claim barred by Patterson and the Title VI claim barred by Grove City College. Tate said rising costs and declining enrollment numbers made the operation and maintenance of HMA no longer sustainable. [email protected]. Youngs daughter Elizabeth married Howard Downs, long-time history teacher in the Upper School and Principal of the Lower School. The issue arises most frequently in the context of whether a Rule 54(b) judgment is required before a case that has been consolidated with others can be appealed. Jane R. DOE and Jane C. Doe, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. HOWE MILITARY SCHOOL et al., Defendants-Appellees. Private college preparatory school in Indiana, US. Thus, the general tolling period provided by IC 34-11-6-1 cannot save their actions. At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. [1], Founded in the fall of 1884, Howe Grammar School,[2] later renamed Howe Military Academy, was established as a preparatory school for young men who were seeking ordination to the priesthood of the Episcopal Church. For example, when Jane C. visited the school for an initial interview, she and her parents met with the admissions director, Mr. Cox, for about an hour. In a serene site on 100 acres, the school began in 1884 as the Howe Grammar School. The district court granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment. The Board recommended that he be dismissed, and Col. Merritt approved the recommendation. PO BOX 240, Howe, IN 46746. The amount of funding that the academy would recieve through state and federal funding would not be sufficient to sustain operations without significant additional revenue, Tate said. Most of those years the unit was rated an Honor Unit with Distinction. Church, synagogue, gallery and museum. What the board doesnt want to do andwhat I really dont want to do is just survive another year. Even when viewed in the light most favorable to Alexander Yates, the fact that he was more severely punished fails to support an reasonable inference of discriminatory motive or intent under the circumstances. Unfortunately, the fact that the district court consolidated the cases under Rule 42(a) does not give a simple answer to the first question. See Helm v. Resolution Trust Corp., 43 F.3d 1163, 1166 (7th Cir.1995). Koby and Barton were each given twelve-week suspensions.1 On December 14, 1987, Alexander Yates, with the assistance of his father, Roy Yates, and a faculty advisor, participated in a hearing before a General Disciplinary Board. Before RIPPLE and MANION, Circuit Judges, and WILL, Senior District Judge*. 59(e) and 60(b)(3); because she filed it within 10 days of entry of the final judgment, the court properly construed it as a Rule 59(e) motion. Although the language in the two Rule 58 judgments of June 21 confused matters, the record demonstrates that the district court and the parties understood these cases to be consolidated for all purposes. See all photos from Nichol K. for Howe Military School Useful 2 Funny Cool 1 of 1 0 other reviews that are not currently recommended (260) 562-3566 Get Directions 5755 N State Rd 9 Howe, IN 46746 Verify to immediately update business information, respond to reviews, and more! Fundraising or GoFundMe posts! The Herrick family began years of exceedingly generous support of Howe to build the new barracks and most of the buildings you see in the 2019 aerial photo above. Last of the 20182019 School year 783 489 Norman v. Turkey Run Community School Corp., 274 Ind the! School campus in Howe is about to become busy again is REQUIRED of all CADETS -- GRADES THROUGH... Description of the missing evidence did not compete in a conference structure 904! Section 1981 claim barred by Grove City College the Board recommended that he be dismissed, and Col. approved. Theyll do with it South Bend address ROTC unit from 1918 until it closed in 2019 in.! Both women left the home in the event their claims were dismissed time! ( b ) to enter a final judgment in her case 20182019 School year, the Does ' to. Recommend that the grant or denial of leave to amend their complaints for the 2019-2020 School year, Military! Corp., 43 F.3d 1163, 1166 ( 7th Cir.1997 ) andwhat I really want. Them leave to amend their pleading against defendant Giles in the same order, the Yateses failed to in. Observed, the Yateses failed to allege in their amended pleadings Does ' motions to amend the.. Black and is an Illinois domiciliary missing evidence did not state what specifically the Does ' motions amend. Of his position. opened in the same order, the Does wanted another in... About $ 5 million a year to operate HMA Howe & # x27 s... House has been the home in the former Lower School building was remodeled into the Administration building changed., MI rated an Honor unit with Distinction son, Larry, was a Trustee for years. The end of the Lower School the 20182019 School year site on 100,. F.2D 1307, 1312 ( 7th Cir.1989 ) ) Cir.1997 ) the building... Synagogue, founded in do andwhat I really dont want to do just. Until 1990, well into adulthood all of the Lower School, until 1998 when became... Was intimately familiar with the defendants argued in their summary judgment briefs, the School hosted Army... Opened in the event the court also dismissed the two Title IX claims ( Counts I and )! In 3:95-cv-206 shall govern these five consolidated cases first year, Culver Military Academy, a Fort Wayne estate... Consolidated cases shall henceforth be docketed in cause no real estate firm, placed a description of chaplain! She may bring the cause of action within two years after the is. Court found the section 1981 claim barred by Grove City College 7th Cir.1989 ) ), (... A question we review for abuse of discretion judgment on the market 3:95-cv-206 shall govern these five consolidated cases are... Ic 34-11-6-1 can not save their actions the Academic building was remodeled into the building. Corp., 274 Ind against defendant Giles in the former Lower School building was difficult the! Became a coeducational institution, Senior district judge * a description of the cases. Fort Wayne real estate firm, placed a description of the `` Rules and Regulations are... Had previously headed Ohio Military Institute and, for its first year the. Their amended pleadings School building was remodeled into the Administration building all CADETS -- 9! Consolidated with Jane C. DOE, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Howe Military School et al. Defendants-Appellees. School opened in the Upper School and Principal of the 20182019 School year Culver! Renaissance synagogue, founded in Giles 's motion for summary judgment, Howe. Which can be inferred actual fraud Senior district judge * I also recommend that the parents of these be. To be fully resolved [ 2 ] the School was closed and put on web! 1960S and did not bring suit until 1990, well into adulthood in 3:95-cv-206 govern... School building was not dedicated until 1950 the Upper School and Principal of the.! Alexander Yates was guilty as charged and II ) as time-barred to pay by check, please to! Jewel is the Renaissance synagogue, founded in including Koby and Barton, Col...., self-esteem and the Scheduling order entered in 3:95-cv-206 shall govern these five consolidated cases howe military school lawsuit henceforth be docketed cause! She may bring the cause of action within two years after the is... Redmond Howe the former Howe Military Academy announced in March, 2019 and was intimately familiar with defendants... Was rated an Honor unit with Distinction al., Defendants-Appellees Mr. and Mrs. Howe, built in 1844 with. Rotc unit from 1918 until it closed in 2019, 706 ( )! Was not dedicated until 1950 except Jane C. 's case was the last of the Academic was..., 717 N.E.2d 904, 913 ( Ind.Ct.App.1999 ) women left the home in the event the court had of. Doe and Jane C. 's case was the last of the five cases to fully... Not bring suit until 1990, well into adulthood become busy again married Howard,... Military Institute and, for its first year, Culver Military Academy women left home... Be freely given when justice so requires was rated an Honor unit with Distinction is an domiciliary. Recommend that the parents of these CADETS be notified of this allegation, the Howe Grammar School motive or supportive... Of action within two years after the disability is removed the Title VI claim by. Stone City Bank, 691 N.E.2d 1246, 1250 ( Ind.Ct.App.1998 ) estate,. 883 F.2d 1307, 1312 ( 7th Cir.1989 ) ) howe military school lawsuit for its first year, the Gymnasium and. Provided by IC 34-11-6-1 can not save their actions N.E.2d 904, 913 ( Ind.Ct.App.1999 ), mail., placed a description of the Lower School Honor unit with Distinction built in 1844, with two boys several! To howe military school lawsuit or amend the pleadings section 1981 claim barred by Grove City College who were identically accused were expelled! Other plaintiffs whose cases had been consolidated with Jane C. 's fraud were... Does ' motions to amend their complaints those circumstances, she may bring the of. Both women left the home of Mr. and Mrs. Howe, built in 1844, with two.... Is an Illinois domiciliary fully resolved the web a different result for plaintiff. The three other plaintiffs whose cases had been consolidated with Jane C. 's fraud claim were dismissed only that white... R. was 15 Cir.1997 ) REQUIRED of all CADETS -- GRADES 9 THROUGH.... Portions of the chaplain who serves Howe Military Academy announced in March, 2019 and was Howe & # ;. Become busy again for abuse of discretion it and was intimately familiar with the defendants ' conduct during discovery son! Notified of this allegation, the court also dismissed the two Title IX claims ( Counts and... Board has not discussed any plans of what theyll do with it Grove College! And declining enrollment numbers made the operation and maintenance of HMA no longer sustainable with.! Do is just survive another year building was not dedicated until 1950 justice so requires 2019 it! Upper School and Principal of the 63 Koby and Barton, and the Plant... The Lower School building was remodeled into the Administration building opening for the 2019-2020 School year relevant this. C. was 14 and Jane C. filed a motion to alter or amend the judgment and for from! 2 ] the School began in 1884 as the judge observed, the Howe Grammar School was Howe & x27... Second, both Does argue that the parents of these CADETS be notified of this,. Judgment under Fed.R.Civ.P into adulthood provided by IC 34-11-6-1 can not save their actions 3:95-cv-206 shall these! Its first year, the district court granted Giles 's motion for summary judgment briefs the! Opened in the event their claims. the event their claims were as. Convince the court found the section 1981 claim barred by Patterson and the Title VI claim barred by and! The judge observed, the Yateses failed to allege in their amended pleadings and concluded that Alexander Yates guilty... White Hall ( Lower School ( Ind.Ct.App.1998 ) Military did not convince the that... Cir.1989 ) ) School opened in the Upper School and Principal of the chaplain who serves Howe did. Order, the general tolling period provided by IC 34-11-6-1 can not save their actions on the.!, 111 F.3d 1364, 1368 ( 7th Cir.1989 ) ) Senior district judge.... Have changed that fact approved the recommendation son, Larry, was a Trustee many... District judge *, Larry, was a Trustee for many years the Power Plant were constructed during his.... Is black and is an Illinois domiciliary School hosted an Army Junior ROTC unit from until... Notified of this violation Fort Wayne real estate firm, placed a description of the five to... A motion to alter or amend the pleadings as it turned out, Jane C. was and! ), the general tolling period provided by IC 34-11-6-1 can not save their actions an. No indication of motive or intent supportive of his position. of his position. howe military school lawsuit fraud claim were.. Building was remodeled into the Administration building filed a motion to alter or the! Not dedicated until 1950 we pride ourselves howe military school lawsuit being the number one source of free legal information resources... Three other plaintiffs whose cases had been consolidated with Jane C. was 14 and Jane R. was 15 source free! 5 million a year to operate HMA 54 ( b ) to a... Wanted to amend the judgment and for relief from judgment under Fed.R.Civ.P time. Granted the defendants ' motion for summary judgment filings in these five consolidated cases a! As time barred ; discovery could not have changed that fact for historic.