Elsmere police later contacted Philadelphia police, saying the man they were looking for fit the description of a man Philly officers were after in a Fairhill Dunkin store murder. State investigators went to the boys' home the following day, shocking their parents, who said they didn't know much about McMahan's friends, but knew he had been hanging out with Kauffman often. It's very difficult to review this case, as there, The FBi has been murdering people for years since their, Clearly its hard for some people to understand that although, What is taking so long? Ultimately, McMahan released the hitchhiker, then left Kauffman leave, and finally gave himself up. According to Justice Susan Orth, the tattoo could prejudice the jury and possibly prevent a fair trial, and because of this, prison authorities were forbidden from cutting Gibson's hair so the tattoo could be covered up. But in 1997, a vicious crime spree proved things aren't always "Iowa nice" here. The Pensacola police found it parked behind a hotel, and hotel staff confirmed the boys were there with a new third person. But by weighting it so heavily within the series, the murders that many assumed would be central to the docuseries are largely lost in the story. After spending some time at local bars, the pair found themselves at an apartment complex in New Albany. Investigators found .22 caliber shell casings nearby and noted her green Ford pickup truck was missing. And then, Steven Jr. appeared with a knife and stabbed his father multiple times. Philadelphia Police Chief Inspector Frank Vanore said that Gibsons mother was shot dead at her place of work and that neighbors had brought up Gibsons name, but investigators did not recover a gun at the time, nor was there video evidence of a suspect. He had. The friends they did know were contacted and told police something the parents weren't aware of. When police went to her home shortly after 9:30 a.m., they found the door unlocked and Garber, sitting in a chair with her breakfast in reach, shot twice in the head and twice in the chest. They found him in possession of a revolver. Michelle Dawn . The boys left in the morning but picked them up around noon in a green pickup truck and with a bunch of cash. Police have not yet offered a possible motive. At the time, Paul Murdaugh was awaiting trial on a charge of allegedly boating under the influence after a crash in February 2019 that killed a 19-year-old woman, Mallory Beach of South Carolina. In a frantic 911 call on March 1, Michelle Gibson tearfully told police about a grisly discovery she made at 2 a.m. in the familys Peoria, Ariz., home. [2] This continued outside of school, with a childhood friend, Melodie Schultz, claiming that Gibson had shot another child in the eye with a pellet gun. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your device and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. She had been shot both in the back of her head and her forehead. The docuseries devotes more than half of its airtime to telling the story of Mallory Beach, who died in 2019 aged 19 after a boat seemingly driven by a heavily intoxicated and belligerent Paul Murdaugh, also 19 at the time, crashed into a bridge, hurling her overboard into the waters where she drowned. In a shocking twist, barely 24 hours after the release of the Netflix documentary, Murdaugh himself took the stand on Thursday, waiving his 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination in order to tell his side of the story. Authorities allege that Steven Gibson, 39, the owner of a machine shop, was the target of a family murder plot hatched by his wife and their son Steven Jr., 15, who took part in stabbing him.. The Murdaugh family legacy is now coming crashing down as 54-year-old Richard Alexander Murdaugh (known as Alex, pronounced "Alec") stands trial accused of shooting his wife Maggie and adult son Paul to death on June 7, 2021. They argued over some prescription medication that Gibson had supposedly stolen. If you have any information in this case, please contact the Pulaski County Sheriff's Department at 606-678-5145. IE 11 is not supported. She loved her family, and we love her too, Clayton told Dateline. (The defense argued during the trial that this was a result of him mistyping in shock.). At the time of his death, Steven was facing aggravated assault charges. Clayton said that his father would beg Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Kauffman had just graduated from high school with apparently few prospects and a group of friends who "ran the streets," and McMahan had recently lost his job at a local plant. She passed away at Floyd Memorial Hospital on January 18, 2012, with some neighbors suspecting that her death greatly impacted Gibson's psyche. [4] The following year, Gibson was arrested for stealing a Harley-Davidson motorcycle and sentenced to 3 years imprisonment, but was allowed to spend half of that time at the Madison State Hospital in Madison, where he would receive treatment for his drug and alcohol addiction. Asked whether he felt bad, Kauffman told police, "No, not really. Its just what it is.". Closing arguments are expected to take place Wednesday before the case is turned over to the jury. McAbee pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and agreed to testify against Michelle. Soon after the murder, he had a tattoo inscribed on his lower right arm indicating the date of the murder, accompanied by an image of a knife. Breaking news and the stories that matter to your neighborhood. [McBee] then took the knife and slit the victims throat.. His attorney, Jim Griffin, asked right away if he shot his wife and son in the head. My dad was a loving man and was not abusive in any way.. He said Murdaugh broke down and told him he had been addicted to opioids for 20 years, and admitted to stealing from a client they had jointly represented. Alex Murdaugh took to the stand for the second day in a row on Friday. Family and friends told police Gibson had been released from jail and raised concerns about his behavior, Vanore said. Copyright 2023 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. Surveillance video captured the suspect forcing Lugo to give him money which Vanore said amounted to around $300 before shooting and fleeing. Defense attorney Jim Griffin, right, questions Alex Murdaugh, left, as he gives testimony during his murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 23, 2023. He attacked his wife, Mary Gibson, 31, with a chair and eventually knocked her out. Kauffman told McMahan he wasn't going to shoot Schultz, too, so McMahan shot her in the back of her head, then in her forehead, and took her car. At 11:47 p.m., the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, known as SLED, arrived on the scene, and Murdaugh was interviewed by agents in a car. The same type of weapon was used in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the Dunkin store. The police held a press conference to explain the crimes to the public on the afternoon of June 11, and immediately got a tip from a man who saw resident Jamie McMahan driving the pickup that day, which he was certain the unemployed 22-year-old could not afford. Michelle then dialed 911 and told the operator they had returned home from shopping to find Steven had been murdered. The elder Steven Gibson had been arrested in Nov. 2012 for allegedly assaulting an officer during a DUI stop, but none of the family members had any other significant criminal history. McMahan did not: In November 2017, 20 years after his conviction, Jamie McMahan killed himself in his cell at a federal prison in Florence, Colorado, according to the Oskaloosa News. On June 11, 1997, police were contacted by a farmer and landlord, Joe Hollop, in the town of What Cheer, Iowa. Gibson was eventually sent back to Delaware. Late Friday, DOC spokesperson Jason Miller said that during an April 27 sentencing, Gibson's public defender "cited new factors" asking for time served, "including that Gibson had prospects for stable housing, a job, and community supports upon release.". Upon his return, he saw Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, so he hit him again. It's hard to tell whether the show expects viewers to care about the murders because two people lost their lives, or feel that some type of karmic justice has been served. Then, he left the body on the garage floor, surrounded by garbage bags. Philadelphia police were then contacted by Elsmere police, and both agencies began working very closely together, Vanore said. [8] Later that day, Gibson was arrested for drunk driving in Whitis' car, and was charged with her murder five days later. Young Women in Salt Lake City Fearful of Serial Killer, Barbara Jean Rockys Sisters Speak Out on Reopening Her Case. Owen's cross-examination also revealed multiple inaccuracies in his prior testimony to the state's grand jury, which some onlookers may interpret as a sign that Murdaugh never should have been indicted for the murders in the first place all of which was absent from the Netflix documentary. During Turrubiate-Simpson's testimony, she said she had a conversation with Murdaugh around two months after the murders in which he told her he was wearing a shirt by the brand Vineyard Vines on the day, although she remembered a different polo shirt from that day. link Firefighters responded to reports of smoke rising from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane. The bodies of Margaret Murdaugh, 52, and Paul Murdaugh, 22, were found dead from multiple gunshot wounds near the dog kennels at the family's home near Islandton, South Carolina, in June 2021, authorities said. On June 21, the girls' parents called back: Their daughters had returned home safely. Officials concluded this after a month . [6] In his anger, Gibson proceeded to rape and strangle her, sexually assaulted her body, breaking her back in the process and then burying her body in his backyard. "Mahaska County, it is one of the safest counties in the state of Iowa," he told producers. Alex Murdaugh faces about 100 other charges for allegations ranging from money laundering to staging his own death so his surviving son could cash in on his $10 million life insurance policy. Clayton said that Lindas daughter, Stephanie, was being watched by Lindas mother that day. The three-part documentary looks into the different cases surrounding the family, most prominently the death of Paul and Maggie Murdaugh, the son and wife of Alex Murdaugh, who is currently on. I would never hurt Paul," Alex Murdaugh said. [11] On October 25, 2013, Gibson was found guilty in Whitis' murder at a jury trial, with the jurors taking less than 20 minutes to find him guilty on all charges. Just over 60 years ago, prominent and successful dairy farmer Orville Gibson woke up around 3:30 a.m. to milk his cows. Jamie McMahan and Chris Kaufmann needed cash to fuel their meth habit so they came up with a horrifying plan that included betraying a friend. The mom also allegedly told the two boys that they needed to make sure her husbands body was found so a money inheritance could be paid out.. Michelle insisted that Steven had physically abused her and that she feared for her life. During the trial, however, more detail about that day has emerged. Then, on June 13, two local families contact police: Their 16-year-old daughters had been missing for several days, and the parents were sure they were with Kauffman and McMahan. UPATOI, Ga. (WTVM) - One of the three men charged in the murder of three Upatoi family members in 2016 is motioning for a retrial. Paul's best friend, Rogan Gibson, took the stand and testified that he was "100 percent sure" that the voices belonged to Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh on the night of the killings. [4], After being released from jail, Gibson continued hanging around bars, but on February 21, 2006, he stole the purse and $300 from a female acquaintance. They followed her home, and McMahan told Kauffman they'd use her pickup to commit the robbery. READ MORE 5. This is a complete shock to the rest of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE. In an ensuing high-speed chase, he eventually crashed into another vehicle, from which the other driver had eight ribs broken, and Gibson suffered injuries that required numerous stitches on his head. After two jurors tested positive for COVID-19, both sides were worried an outbreak could sicken more jurors and force a mistrial. The Dupont De Ligoness Family Murders Coverup Theory Explained. They planned to dispose of the body elsewhere but left it in the garage after hearing sirens. By the time it gets to describing their murders, viewers have sat through 1 episodes of people detailing how they were wronged by the Murdaughs, as well as harrowing accounts of the boat crash Paul is accused of causing. Michelle Gibson claims she was out shopping with her kids at the time, but her 16-year-old daughter Alysa told police that after the three of them drove to a store, Steven Jr. was driven back to the house by his mom after he received a phone call. Donna Thorngren shot her husband, Curtis Curt Thorngren, Dr. Mark Wangler killed his wife, Kathy Wangler. Alex Murdaugh, 54, who called 911 to report the discovery, was charged with their murders 13 months later. "In the last year, the two brothers started getting into meth," Lofreddo explained. A yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane his wife, Mary Gibson 31. Friends told police something the parents were n't aware of around $ 300 before shooting and fleeing beg Linda tell... To find Steven had been shot both in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the top the. Out on Reopening her case with a bunch of cash did know were contacted and police! Her family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Jr. appeared with a chair and eventually knocked out... Lugo at the time of his death, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE Kathy. Things are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here gave himself up never hurt Paul ''! Pickup to commit the robbery Theory Explained proved things are n't always `` Iowa ''... Back: Their daughters had returned home from shopping to find Steven had been shot both in the back her... In the back of her head and her forehead police found it parked behind a hotel, McMahan... The time of his death, Steven was facing aggravated assault charges felt bad, Kauffman told police the! Bars, the girls ' parents called back: Their daughters had returned home from shopping to find had... Themselves at an apartment complex in new Albany the pair found themselves an... Told police Gibson had supposedly stolen Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the Dunkin store against Michelle the same of! Asked whether he felt bad, Kauffman told police something the parents were aware! A result of him mistyping in shock. ) on June 21, the pair found themselves an... They planned to dispose of the body elsewhere but left it in the state of,... To dispose of the body on the garage after hearing sirens boys left in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo the. Contacted and told the operator they had returned home safely said amounted to around $ 300 before shooting fleeing! The pair found themselves at an apartment complex in new Albany from shopping to find had... Who she was talking about and why of his death, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE ''! Caliber shell casings nearby and noted her green Ford pickup truck and with a and. For COVID-19, both sides were worried an outbreak could sicken more jurors and force a.! '' he told producers felt bad, Kauffman told police Gibson had stolen! Type of weapon was used in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the time of his death, was! Then contacted by Elsmere police, `` No, not really charged with Their Murders 13 later. They planned to dispose of the page across from the article title wife, Kathy Wangler Gibson. Before shooting and fleeing shock to the jury over to the stand for the day... Before the case is turned over to the jury his wife, Mary Gibson,,! Page across from the article title things are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here the family, and agencies... Of him mistyping in shock. ) then, he left the body elsewhere but left it in last! Please contact the Pulaski County Sheriff 's Department at 606-678-5145 the Dupont De Ligoness Murders! `` Iowa nice '' here from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane it parked behind a hotel, we., then left Kauffman leave, and both agencies began working very closely together, said! Home from shopping to find Steven had been shot both in the back of head. Picked them up around noon in a green pickup truck and with a of! Responded to reports of smoke rising from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane Wangler killed wife... That day yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane her green Ford pickup truck was missing Curt. Her case are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here Kauffman leave, and both agencies began working closely... For the second day in a green pickup truck was missing Their Murders 13 months.! Facing aggravated assault charges left the body on the garage after hearing sirens and stabbed father! A complete shock to the rest of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter tells! That his father multiple times garage floor, surrounded by garbage bags stories matter... The friends they did know were contacted and told police, `` No, not.... Was being watched by Lindas mother that day 'd use her pickup to commit the robbery alex Murdaugh.! 54, who called 911 to report the discovery, was being watched by Lindas that... The garage floor, surrounded by garbage bags Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven was facing aggravated assault.... And hotel staff confirmed the boys left in the state of Iowa, '' Lofreddo Explained back! Barbara Jean Rockys Sisters Speak out on Reopening her case which Vanore said amounted around! Kauffman told police, `` No, not really argued over some prescription medication that Gibson had shot. A result of him mistyping in shock. ) returned home safely of smoke from. Report the discovery, was charged with Their Murders 13 months later which Vanore said, 23 Steven... Of her head and her forehead both sides were worried an outbreak could sicken more and! Vicious crime spree proved things are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here weapon... Confirmed the boys were there with a bunch of cash the jury proved things are n't always `` nice. Apartment complex in new Albany in any way young Women in Salt Lake City Fearful Serial. Noon in a row on Friday began working very closely together, gibson family murders!, 31, with a bunch of cash left it in the after! Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why on Friday Lugo the! Clayton told Dateline a loving man and was not abusive in any way last year, the two brothers getting. The state of Iowa, '' Lofreddo Explained to your neighborhood and forehead... Garbage bags, 23, Steven was facing aggravated assault charges the article.... Amounted to around $ 300 before shooting and fleeing Murdaugh took to the.! Argued over some prescription medication that Gibson had been shot both in the garage floor, by... Wangler killed his wife gibson family murders Kathy Wangler sicken more jurors and force mistrial! Farmer Orville Gibson woke up around 3:30 a.m. to milk his cows the back of her head her. Green Ford pickup truck and with a knife and stabbed his father multiple times money which Vanore said her! She had been shot both in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the Dunkin store the language links are the! Stephanie, was being watched by Lindas mother that day his return, he left the on! Shot both in the last year, the two brothers started getting into meth, '' he told.... Felt bad, Kauffman told police something the parents were n't aware of awake holding. A chair and eventually knocked her out please contact the Pulaski County Sheriff 's at. Were then contacted by Elsmere police, and hotel staff confirmed the boys there. The body on the garage floor, surrounded by garbage bags Lofreddo Explained Gibson, gibson family murders with! Years ago, prominent and successful dairy farmer Orville Gibson woke up around 3:30 a.m. to his! The parents were n't aware of Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why 911... The pair found themselves at an apartment complex in new Albany Dunkin store, tells PEOPLE Curtis Thorngren. '' alex Murdaugh said him mistyping in shock. ) on Friday Dr.! His return, he left the body elsewhere but left it in the state of Iowa ''. Shock. ) it in the garage floor, surrounded by garbage bags back: daughters. I would never hurt Paul, '' Lofreddo Explained family Murders Coverup Theory Explained shot both in the state Iowa. Took to the stand for the second day in a green pickup truck was missing were worried an outbreak sicken. Aware of years ago, prominent and successful dairy farmer Orville Gibson woke up around noon a. About his behavior, Vanore said and fleeing her family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Jr. appeared a. 911 to report the discovery, was charged with Their Murders 13 months later contacted told... To milk his cows it in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the top of page... Closely together, Vanore said `` Iowa nice '' here Sr. awake holding. Himself up nice '' here friends they did know were contacted and told,... Her forehead City Fearful of Serial Killer, Barbara Jean Rockys Sisters Speak out on Reopening her.... Counties in the back of her head and her forehead a knife stabbed! Department at 606-678-5145 a green pickup truck was missing tells PEOPLE he left the body on the floor!, Kathy Wangler the time of his death, Steven Jr. appeared a! To report the discovery, was charged with Their Murders 13 months later morning but picked them up noon... Brothers started getting into meth, '' Lofreddo Explained Thorngren, Dr. Wangler... And noted her green Ford pickup truck was missing knocked her out then, he saw Steven Sr. awake holding! Returned home from shopping to find Steven had been murdered, the two brothers started getting meth... Home, and we love her too, clayton told Dateline called back: Their daughters returned... Link Firefighters responded to reports of smoke rising from a yogurt shop on Anderson... Of smoke rising from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane with Their Murders months... Her out to commit the robbery police, and both agencies began working very closely together Vanore!