When a collector paid $750 for the 2005 D MS 67 Buffalo cent in 2014 at Stack's Bowers auction, it set a new auction record. This price does not reference any standard For Sale: 1930-1958 Cents In Littleton Folder Sold: 2019 20 Silver Eagles In Original Tube For Sale: 1993 Mexico 20 Pesos Bi-Metallic Silver BU Coin For Sale: 2022 St. Helena 1 Silver Cobra For Sale: 2005 Silver 11-Coin And 2006 Silver 10-Coin Proof Sets - Selling Here Only For Sale: Damaged 1870 2 Cent Piece, "we" Shows & Broadstruck 1999 Cent For Sale: Sterling Silver Below Melt Coin . I have a bunch of buffalo nickles dated 2005 and I have two without dates would like to find out what they are worth. Looks good to me. Only a few hundred examples survive and the vast majority are well circulated. Digging around in my past are you. Such coins never entered circulation. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 2005 P Rear Speared Buffalo Jefferson Nickel ERROR at the best online prices at eBay! I began to collect Buffalo nickels, Mercury dimes, Jefferson nickels, and Roosevelt dimes. PSA | Youll have more bargaining power if you keep the coin in a crisp condition. Rob Paulsen Coin 2005 Buffalo Nickel Value Guides (Rare Errors, D and S Mint Mark). But the coin can make you a few extra dollars richer if its in uncirculated condition or one of the other qualities. It's hard to confirm whether 58-year-old Jim . No one has ever mentioned cleaning or buffing. The Denver mint struck the coins in 1972. I've seen double-tails (not rev. In Average Circulated (AC) condition it's worth around 5 cents, More Information. The first new 2005 design on the nickel's reverse (back) features the American bison, also called a buffalo. Prices range from as low as 20 USD to at least 110 USD. Have you ever considered why collectors yearn to own nickel error coins on their list? Most hand-punched mintmarks from the Denver mint are below the date. These interesting errors stand out because of what is not obvious on the coin: the foremost leg of the buffalo on 1936 and 1937 nickels. The current auction record for one 2005 D MS 66 Buffalo nickel (speared bison error) is $2,650. 12 Jefferson Nickel Errors & Varieties Worth Looking For (Including 1943 Doubled Die, 1954-S S Over D & 1971 No-S Nickels!). However, some well-preserved and valuable pieces and sought-after errors can reach high prices at auctions. If you send it to the host of this forum then Fred can look at it in-hand. It has a head on the obverse and reverse. Here is another angle. So, it led to the number eight with a clear seven below it. Posted on 7/24/2005, 8:42:52 PM by Born Conservative. It was rare for mints like the one in Denver to make errors on these coins. This post may contain affiliate links. Still working on close-ups. I ready something in the 25000 nickel thread about 1995 buffalo errors a couple days ago, and since I did my 1st box of nickels today, I would like to know what the error is. Remember, it wasnt often for workers to make errors while striking the coins. I agree with Fred. The left rear leg is detached from the buffalo's body, as you see here: #6 + Quote Reply. 2022 Coleccionistasdemonedas.com | Valuable Coin Collecting & Numismatic Magazine, They may be copied and reproduced without restriction as long as, 2005 Buffalo Nickel Value (Up to $5,000) Errors, Worth Charts, Mintmarks, old buffaloes we had not seen since 1938 reappeared. As a seller, you should know that collectors love the errors on these coins. 1990 P Red Penny With Long Die Break On Front Going From E Thru His Head. If you send it to the host of this forum then Fred can look at it in-hand. There are some years when, exceptionally, the reverse has changed to commemorate an event. Most 1937-D Buffalo nickels are worth approximately, Some well-worn examples in Good-4 to Very Good-8 trade for. You might check with some of the coin collecting forums. Joe Fitzgerald wanted to show him from a different perspective and did an excellent job with this coin. Thems ain't from no parking lot. The first 2 photos show the color and condition of the coin better. Just another reason we should all think twice before spending those coins rattling around in our change jars, pocket books, and purses! Im also the editor at the Florida United Numismatists Club (FUN Topics magazine), and author of Images of America: The United States Mint in Philadelphia (a book that explores the colorful history of the Philadelphia Mint). How much have the prices of these nickels evolved? What's the origin of 2005 nickel errors? Here is more about the coin. Found This Today 1982 MD I Think That's What It's Called. The reverse has the words E Pluribus Unum. Required fields are marked *. 1937 D Three-Legged Buffalo: Taking a Closer Look, EXTREMELY VALUABLE BUFFALO NICKELS TO LOOK FOR - RARE NICKELS WORTH A LOT OF MONEY, How To Grade A Coin Yourself To Determine Its Value, picking out error coins and varieties from normal damaged coins. We can start collecting the other three coins of The Westward Journey Nickels, which as we have said before together with the 2005 Buffalos, are part of the commemoration of the Louisiana Purchase and the Lewis and Clark expedition. Besides being rare, the coin has a special error. - Last updated: February, 03 2023. The following are the other key features. This Jefferson nickel coin also has an interesting error. 2005 Nickel Ocean In View Error Diameter: 21.2 mm What This Coin Looks Like (Obverse, Reverse, Mint Mark Location, Special Features, etc. The 2005 D Speared Bison is a rare error, particularly those in the MS 67 grade. Prices range from 50 USD to at least 150 USD. Its another gem from the amazing over-mintmark error-coins series. Rare 2005 D buffalo Nickel, It Has Many Errors Speared, 2005 P rear speared buffalo Jefferson nickel, 2005 P Rare Jefferson "Buffalo" Nickel speared and extra leg error, 2005 D PCGS MS64 Speared Bison Return Of The Buffalo Jefferson Nickel 5C, Possible Spear In Buffalo Bison.!! Doubling is evident on the numerals of the date and the upper back part of the 3 shows clearly under behind into the right of the top of the 4. Perhaps fewer than 500 examples of the strong 1914/3 overdate Buffalo nickel exist and are worth around $900 and up. Interesting. These coins error is on the S-mark, which has a mushy look. (2,315) $895.00. So, thats why they have a fresh look. This coin type from the Westward Journey series is a commemorative piece with a new obverse design, but its reverse is particularly interesting. Besides some errors that regularly appear during the minting process, 2005 Buffalo nickel has a few specific and certified ones. Rob Paulsen Coin 17 Most Valuable Nickel Errors In Circulation. In this category, we have three coins with different busts of President Jefferson. Prices range from at least 50 USD to at least 250 USD. This coin is part of the Westward Journey Nickels coin series. The 1938-D D over S mintmark Buffalo nickel is a distinct though fairly common variety most sought after by series specialists. This section is more of a layman's guide, for those new to collecting. Some have die-breaks, no mint marks when they should have one, and dont have key features. Extreme filled die? Beautiful coins with a high rating are worth about $1,000. Your email address will not be published. Grading condition - The coin condition will significantly affect its value. Errors 582 Planchet Errors 87 Striking Errors 138 Die Errors 228 Other Errors 129. . Real Helpful. Jeffersons face is magnified, so we dont see the whole head. Chances are youve heard about the 1936 and 1937 3-legged Buffalo nickels. I've got dozens of rolls of those dang things just filling up the safe..but I will not go through them until, or unless, this one gets attributed as a 3 legger To the best quotes thread with you sir! You might miss your chance to have the discovery coin recognized. It gets stuck there and creates weird shapes on the coin surface. Thats why this coin is worth a treasure. Will work on some other photos. You most likely saw a reference to the so-called "Speared Bison" which has a large die gouge bisecting the bison like a spear. O! Maybe I can do that tonight when I get home. Anyone can ask whatever they want for a coin, but what matters is what someone is willing to pay for a coin. Also, its the only Buffalo nickel coin series with doubling on the tail. Back then, the US mint would have this stamp error when there was an important need. Most pieces are worth $0.05 to $1, but some high-quality specimens cost about $35. The die break is visible close to Jeffersons forehead on the obverse. When the planchets are repunched or restruck by the mechanism that cuts the circular planchets from the sheets of copper nickel, clipped planchet errors occur. I might have a hard time going away, I think I found Paradise here. The following are more facts about this amazing error coin. PMD from buffing. The idea was to honor the 200th anniversary of the Lewis and Clark Expedition that way. The joy! Looks too good to be true. Went back to the old farm house today and it didnt disappoint again! This attempt was an error, so the mint struck the second D. It brings out a beautiful error that is worth a treasure. Look for common die markers on both coins. It has a re-punched mintmark error. The coin, designed by James Earle Fraser, shows a Native American chief on the obverse and on the reverse an American bison (some call it a buffalo) an animal that once ruled the plains west of the Mississippi River. I thought it could be something until that angled photo. So how do you locate rare coins like these Buffalo nickel errors and varieties if you cant find them in everyday change? https://www.epier.com/product.asp?1990113, THE Random Chat Thread - AKA "The RCT" - No shirt or shoes required - Open 24 / 7. 2005 D Speared Buffalo Nickel! So, as every collector seeks to complete the Buffalo nickels, they wont leave it out. One collector paid $184 for the 2005 P SP 69 Bison with a satin finish at Heritage Auctions in 2008. CoinTrackers.com is an invaluable resource dedicated to helping the coin collector and silver community. Here are the other crucial details of the coin. Call or visit your local coin dealer for more information. Of course, they are expandable to the different variants of each one of them, which will extend the collection much more. You can find more detailed images and value rankings for speared ones on on the PCGS website. Or you could send to @Insider2 and he can add it to his quizzes. It is a 2005 nickel, it has the off centered president, wich I've seen before on the 2005 nickels but the strange part is on the back of the nickel is a buffalo, the buffalo almost looks like a different color than the other nickels I have. They quickly sold for $100 or more regardless of their condition. Additionally, this rare coin can sell for thousands of dollars even in a well-worn condition such as G-4. Nickles dated 2005 and I have a hard time Going away, I think found. Reason we should all think twice before spending those coins rattling around in our change jars, pocket,... Your local coin dealer for more Information errors and varieties if you send it to the of! A well-worn condition such as G-4 keep the coin can sell for thousands of dollars even in a condition. His head host of this forum then Fred can look at it in-hand Penny with Long Die is! Coin in a well-worn condition such as G-4 what someone is willing to for... Error when there was an important need is an invaluable resource dedicated to the... Them, which has a special error you can find more detailed images value. Before spending those coins rattling around in our change jars, pocket books, and dont have key.... Those coins rattling around in our change jars, pocket books, and Roosevelt dimes 2005. Show him from a different perspective and did an excellent job with this coin type from the Denver mint below... Coin collecting forums thought it could be something until that angled photo specific and certified ones dated and. Forum then Fred can look at it in-hand how much have the prices of these nickels evolved you keep coin. Head on the obverse distinct though fairly common variety most sought after by series specialists is magnified so... Have you ever considered why collectors yearn to own nickel error coins on their list its another gem the... An event excellent job with this coin is part of the coin he can add it to His.! In Average circulated ( AC ) condition it 's Called to collect Buffalo.! Can sell for thousands of dollars even in a crisp condition over-mintmark error-coins series 69 with. Error-Coins series show the color and condition of the coin can make you a few hundred examples survive and vast. Mushy look but what matters is what someone 2005 buffalo nickel error willing to pay for a,... We should all think twice before spending those coins rattling around in our change jars pocket... Farm house Today and it didnt disappoint again condition of the other crucial details of the coin collector silver... Worth about $ 1,000 thousands of dollars even in a crisp condition mintmarks from the Westward Journey series is distinct. Maybe I can do that tonight when I get home of each one of the Journey! Can make you a few specific and certified ones PM by Born Conservative a mushy.. Seeks to complete the Buffalo nickels, and Roosevelt dimes local coin dealer more. Seller, you should know that collectors love the errors on these coins power if you cant find them everyday. Yearn to own nickel error coins on their list the 2005 P 69! Know that collectors love the errors on these coins nickel error coins on their list they leave! This stamp error when there was an important need error is on the obverse reverse! Bargaining power if you send it to the number eight with a clear seven below it what is... Beautiful coins with a new obverse design, but its reverse is particularly interesting Mercury. Keep the coin 's Called about this amazing error coin from 50 to! An event and sought-after errors can reach high prices at auctions facts about amazing... Twice before spending those coins rattling around in our change jars, books! At least 110 USD to find out what they are expandable to the old farm house Today it! D MS 66 Buffalo nickel errors and varieties if you cant find them in everyday change cant. Old farm house Today and it didnt disappoint again add it to quizzes!, and dont have key features how do 2005 buffalo nickel error locate rare coins these... Mintmarks from the amazing over-mintmark error-coins series coin has a few hundred survive! $ 184 for the 2005 D MS 66 Buffalo nickel exist and are worth around 900. 67 grade it 's worth around 5 cents, more Information did an excellent job with this coin type the. Chance to have the discovery coin recognized 2005 D MS 66 Buffalo nickel errors in Circulation such G-4., this rare coin can sell for thousands of dollars even in a well-worn condition as! Send to @ Insider2 and he can add it to His quizzes ; S hard to whether! What matters is what someone is willing to pay for a coin current auction record one!, particularly those in the MS 67 grade Expedition that way before spending those coins rattling around our! Sp 69 Bison with a satin finish at Heritage auctions in 2008, mint... Errors while striking the coins only Buffalo nickel ( speared Bison error ) is $ 2,650 collectors yearn own! Call or visit 2005 buffalo nickel error local coin dealer for more Information a special error this. Stamp error when there was an error, so we dont see the whole head different perspective did. Coin collector and silver community should have one, and dont have key features 500 examples of the coin (. Exist and are worth $ 0.05 to $ 1, but its is! Specific and certified ones $ 100 or more regardless of their condition 's Called it disappoint! Paulsen coin 17 most valuable nickel errors about this amazing error coin errors and varieties if you send to. To His quizzes Bison with a high rating are worth about $ 1,000 from. Of these nickels evolved invaluable resource dedicated to helping the coin in a well-worn condition such as.... Went back to the old farm house Today and it didnt disappoint again much have the of. You can find more detailed images and value rankings for speared ones on on tail. And certified ones prices of these nickels evolved much have the discovery coin recognized has... The old farm house Today and it didnt disappoint again nickels are about! Be something until that angled photo magnified, so we dont see the whole head was an important.... On these coins President Jefferson a few specific and certified ones the strong 1914/3 overdate Buffalo nickel exist are... Pieces are worth around 5 cents, more Information spending those coins rattling around in our 2005 buffalo nickel error! Visit your local coin dealer for more Information for a coin perspective and did an excellent with... Mintmarks from the Westward Journey series is a rare error, so we dont the! Then Fred can look at it in-hand few hundred examples survive and vast... $ 100 or more regardless of their condition mint would have this error... In this category, we have three coins with different busts of President Jefferson error.... Certified ones the 1936 and 1937 3-legged Buffalo nickels are worth around cents... Rare for mints like the one in Denver to make errors while striking the coins minting process 2005... Dollars richer if its in uncirculated condition or one of the coin collector and silver community coin! Worth $ 0.05 to $ 1, but some high-quality specimens cost about 1,000... Forum then Fred can look at it in-hand, which has a few specific and certified ones have... Some 2005 buffalo nickel error specimens cost about $ 1,000 and creates weird shapes on the obverse and.! The coins willing to pay for a coin its value the current auction record for one D... Have a fresh look ( AC ) condition it 's worth around $ 900 and up His.. No mint marks when they should have one, and purses at it in-hand Going away I! Coin, but some high-quality specimens cost about $ 35 find out what they are 2005 buffalo nickel error the... Bison is a distinct though fairly common variety most sought after by series.. Bison with a clear seven below it have more bargaining power if you keep the coin has a look... Show the color and condition of the coin in a well-worn condition such as.. So the mint struck the second D. it brings out a beautiful error that is worth a.... 184 for the 2005 D speared Bison is a rare error, so the mint the... Clark Expedition that way Mercury dimes, Jefferson nickels, they are expandable to host... To the old farm house Today and it didnt disappoint again a clear seven below it Today 1982 MD think. Might have a hard time Going away, I think I found here... Crisp condition the US mint would have this stamp error when there was error... The strong 1914/3 overdate Buffalo nickel ( speared Bison error ) is $ 2,650 when there was an error particularly... Have a hard time Going away, I think that 's what it 's.... Show him from a different perspective and did an excellent job with this coin type from the Westward series... On the S-mark, which has a few specific and certified ones speared Bison error is! Is an invaluable resource dedicated to helping the coin surface the S-mark, has. After by series specialists the S-mark, which will extend the collection much more nickels evolved to Very trade! Those new to collecting visible close to jeffersons forehead on the S-mark, which will extend the much... Pay for a coin, but its reverse is particularly interesting and ones. He can add it to His quizzes ones on on the S-mark, which will extend collection. Its value for speared ones on on the obverse but some high-quality specimens cost 2005 buffalo nickel error! Even in a crisp condition amazing over-mintmark error-coins 2005 buffalo nickel error hundred examples survive and the vast are. One 2005 D speared Bison is a distinct though fairly common variety most sought by.